When Jewish Converts Speak: Trump, Israel & Christian Discernment. Jewish Christian voices like Henry Makow challenge evangelical Zionism and warn of political manipulation through Trump and Israel. A call for biblical discernment.

In an age dominated by disinformation, partisan loyalty, and eschatological confusion, few voices have more to offer than Jewish converts to Christianity who stand at the crossroads of faith, heritage, and prophetic clarity. Their testimonies — often overlooked — challenge both mainstream Jewish and Evangelical assumptions about Israel, Zionism, and geopolitics. Among these voices, individuals like Henry Makow have become known for sounding the alarm: that the Church is being manipulated, and that Donald Trump may be serving as a political vassal to the Zionist elite.

Trump, Israel, and the Evangelical Zionist Alliance

Donald Trump’s presidency was marked by unprecedented support for the modern state of Israel. From moving the U.S. Embassy to Jerusalem to recognizing the Golan Heights as Israeli territory, to the Abraham Accords reshaping Arab-Israeli relations, Trump became an icon among pro-Israel Evangelicals. But this relationship also raised red flags.

Jewish critics — including converts like Henry Makow — noted that Trump's administration was deeply intertwined with Chabad-Lubavitch networks and Zionist financiers. Jared Kushner, Trump's son-in-law, was raised in an Orthodox Jewish household with strong Chabad ties. These associations, some argue, suggest that Trump’s foreign policy was less about Christian prophecy and more about fulfilling the objectives of modern political Zionism.

What Jewish Converts See That Evangelicals Often Miss

Many Jewish believers in Jesus bring a crucial corrective: they distinguish between biblical Israel — the covenant people of God — and modern political Israel — a secular, militarized nation-state that often acts contrary to the justice and mercy taught by the prophets.

They warn that:

• Political Zionism is not synonymous with God’s covenant.

• Biblical prophecy does not justify unchecked violence or ethnic suppression.

• Supporting Israel should not mean ignoring the suffering of Christians and Muslims in the region.

In short, they call Christians back to biblical discernment — not blind loyalty.

Henry Makow and the "Trump-Israel Agenda"

Henry Makow, a Jewish-born author and creator of the board game "Scruples" now identifies with Christian values. He has long criticized what he calls the Zionist manipulation of Western political systems. He argues that Trump, far from being a savior of American conservatism, has been deployed by Zionist interests to further Middle Eastern destabilization, particularly against Iran.

Makow points to:

• Trump’s military posturing against Iran

• Support for Netanyahu’s aggressive policies

• The sidelining of Palestinian Christians

While not all of Makow’s claims are accepted in the mainstream, his concerns echo those of many independent Jewish and Christian thinkers who fear that the Gospel has been hijacked by political agendas.

Other Jewish Voices with Similar Warnings

Makow is not alone. Other Jewish believers and sympathetic observers have voiced concern:

• Brother Nathanael Kapner, an Orthodox convert, frequently critiques Zionist overreach and its impact on Christian witness.

• Barry Chamish (deceased), an Israeli journalist, uncovered elite agendas behind the scenes of Israeli politics, questioning the authenticity of political-religious alignments.

• Numerous Messianic Jewish communities affirm a high view of Scripture while rejecting modern Zionism as a prophetic fulfillment.

These perspectives often alienate them from both mainstream Jewish and Evangelical camps — but they speak with rare prophetic insight.

The Danger of Mistaking Nationalism for Prophecy

One of the greatest errors of the modern Church is confusing the political interests of a nation with the eternal purposes of God. The prophets rebuked Israel for this repeatedly. Isaiah and Jeremiah warned of trusting in alliances and oppressing the vulnerable while claiming divine favor.

Evangelicals today must ask:

• Is our support for Israel biblical, or political?

• Are we excusing injustice in the name of eschatology?

• Have we allowed political narratives to replace the message of the cross?

Conclusion: A Call to Prophetic Clarity

The crisis of Christian discernment in our time is not just about Trump, or Netanyahu, or the Middle East. It is about whether the Church will return to the voice of the Good Shepherd — or continue being manipulated by media, politics, and untested theological assumptions.

Jewish converts who now follow Jesus are offering the Church a wake-up call. They are not betraying Israel; they are pleading with the Church to see clearly.

"My sheep hear my voice, and I know them, and they follow me." — John 10:27 (WEB)

caring is sharing